
THIS IS NOT A FULL REVIEW. Gotta make sure you all understand that before going any further.
So this is the first experience I’m having really taking a good listen to some Brand New, and I figured I’d share it because they seem to be quite the influential band and they seem to have almost a cult like following.
Anyway, I started with Daisy. It was the controversial record that I’ve heard the most complaints about, so I wanted to hear it for myself with no bias whatsoever that’s based upon how it compares to the older stuff.
But having not heard the old stuff didn’t make a difference. I can hear, even through this single listen, that this was going to alienate people. It has all the workings of a likeable collection of songs, but it’s organized in such a way that can only be described with the word I’ve seen many people throwing around like nothing: jarring. Looking back, it feels like I’ve been listening to a gentle guitar riff with some syncopated drum beats and a lot of bass for most of the album. But then I realize that the end of “You Stole” and the choruses of “Sink” exploded with a barrage of loud guitars and shrill yelling and just mad noise. But mad in the best way, mainly because it mostly sounds like its sole intention is to be off putting to the listener as soon as they get used to the soft parts. Brand New clearly had the intention to turn some heads here.
That being said, every individual section of this album is met with brilliant execution. If the part feels out of place, the vocals seem like they’re given just the right amount of carelessness to match it. Once again, this is their way of displaying madness in a good way. And when they go for the parts that feel completely at home, there’s a careful precision heard in the guitar, where no notes are added where they won’t enhance the listening experience. All the right guitar effects and production tweaks are in all the right places. The drums never stick to a by-the-book rhythm unless enough is going on outside of them to keep anyone from noticing. The bass shines through whenever the guitar and drums feel like they’re slipping out of the foreground. At every turn, this album feels right. Is everyone going to like it? No. It’s a strikingly erratic display of pure madness attempting to take the form of a refined alternative rock album. But if you don’t, you’ll listen to every little detail, you’ll appreciate the craftsmanship it took for Brand New to create such a technically brilliant record, and you’ll be perfectly okay with the fact that Daisy is just not your speed.








